Friday, November 20, 2009

How was this investigation started?

This entry perhaps should have been posted first. I apologize for posting this late.

A frequently asked question about the recent investigation of Dr. Anilir's career is how it was started and spread recently, after the negligence over several years. Some people suspect (or try to downplay our effort by claiming) that it must come from personal resentment, which is completely wrong as you will understand by reading the following.

First, I have to clarify that what I am reporting on this blog is mostly not my own research, but result of collective efforts by many people (I also contribute as one of them, but my share is tiny.)

It seems that some people had suspicion about Dr. Anilir before. However, if you do not have a solid evidence, it would be difficult to accuse someone. It also involves certain risk.

Dr. Anilir was fairly well known, but he was not famous enough. Many people had not (and perhaps still have not) heard about him. Things might have changed a little, when an article featuring Dr. Anilir appeared as one of the "Front Runner" special series article in Asahi Shimbun (newspaper) on August 29th, 2009. Asahi is one of the largest newspapers in Japan (officially, 8 million copies are printed for every issue), and it featured him in substantial depth (full 1 and 1/2 page) -- although most of the content now seems to be fantasy. The "Front Runner" series featured, for example, Bill Gates in the past. Maybe he got more attention because of this article in Asahi Shimbun.

Then enters "2 channel" -- the largest internet forum in Japan. Most postings there are made anonymously, and the quality of the postings varies wildly. Some people (especially those in traditional mass media) tend to downplay or ridicule internet forums, especially "2 channel". In fact, occasionally, some stupid people use "2 channel" to announce criminal acts and get arrested. (You can usually maintain anonymity at "2 channel", but they keep the access log and disclose to law enforcement agencies upon official request. Announcement to kill someone is a crime by itself, so the police will investigate and ask for the log!)

On the other hand, although it is overlooked by traditional media, some serious (and often very professional) discussions also take place in "2 channel". It has many sub-forums (called ita or "boards" in "2 channel"), and several of them are devoted to sciences. On the "Sciences - General" board, there was a thread on paper submission, where people were discussing how to write a paper and go through the review process, etc.

Meanwhile, someone got to know about Dr. Anilir (maybe from the Asahi article, but I don't know) and looked at his publication list in his web page at the University of Tokyo. At a glance, it looked like a normal publication list with many papers. But he or she noticed that there was a very strange "paper" in the listing -- Physical Review Letters published by Cambridge University Press, and the article is claimed to have more than 10 pages. Anyone with some research experience in physics would immediately smell something strange. I am not sure if anybody with physics background looked at the publication list previously in Japan. Maybe someone noticed, but did not know how to deal with it. Actually, we learned that "feyerabend" (who I think also contributes to this blog) did notice the problem with PRL (and some others) and posted to Turkish internet forum(?) "sourtimes" earlier, on May 18th, 2009. Maybe our "2 channel" just has more population to start a large-scale movement.

Anyway, in Japan, the person who noticed the problem with "Physical Review Letters" paper posted the finding to the thread discussing paper submission, in "Sciences - General" board of "2 channel". It was on September 5th, 2009, just one week after the article in Asahi Shimbun. It got attention of scientists participating in the same thread, and on September 9th, a new thread to discuss exclusively the "Serkan affair" was started. The story was spread gradually over "2 channel" (especially science-related boards) and attracted quite a few scientists and engineers. I am just one of them.

Later, the information was spread not only in "2 channel" but also through other internet media. Investigation was also extended in other places, in particular at Japanese blog where the findings of "2 channel" are also summarized. This is also an interesting subject in the history of this affair, but let me stop here for now. I just mention that the "Serkan affair thread" in "2 channel" is now 10th in its series. Every thread is closed after 1,000 postings, so there have been almost 10,000 postings in the "Serkan affair thread" so far.

Anyhow, the current investigation was ignited by the anonymous posting in "2 channel" on September 5th. Most of the people involved in the investigation, including myself, did not know about Dr. Anilir before that epoch-making posting, so there was not even a chance to have any personal resentment. It is also interesting to recall that "2 channel" is often regarded as a crazy, underground place, especially by traditional media. At least concerning Dr. Anilir, however, it quickly accumulated most precise information which was not known by newspapers or authorities like the University of Tokyo.

51 comments:

  1. Replies


    1. - Thật sao? Nói vậy, ngươi hẳn là Tông chủ của Vân Thiên Tông phải không?

      - Vãn bối chính là Tông chủ của Vân Thiên Tông, còn mong tiền bối không làm khó cho một tiểu phái như Vân Thiên Tông ta…

      Thanh âm của Lý Mộ Uyển từ từ truyền đến, vẫn rất êm tai, đầy vẻ nhu nhược.

      Triển Bạch hừ nhẹ một tiếng nói:

      - Ta thật muốn nhìn mỹ nhân Tông chủ của Vân Thiên Tông rốt cuộc bộ dáng như thế nào!
      mu private cho thuê nhà trọ cho thuê nhà trọ nhạc sàn cực mạnh tư vấn pháp luật qua điện thoại công ty luật số điện thoại tư vấn pháp luật dịch vụ thành lập công ty
      Nói xong, tay phải hắn vươn lên, hướng về mây trắng giữa không trung, hung hăng chụp xuống.

      Chỉ nghe rắc rắc mấy tiếng, mây trắng lập tức tan vỡ. Chẳng qua, sau khi tan ra lại nhanh chóng ngưng tụ lại lần nữa.

      - Ah, Trận pháp này cũng có chỗ thần kỳ, không phải là do Vân Thiên Tông ngươi bố trí!

      Ánh mắt Triển Bạch chợt loé lên.

      Delete
  2. Hi Nakres,

    Thanks for sharing with us how this all started. Still the question, how he got away with his fake identity past ten years is not answered, which is obviously has nothing to do with you.

    What do you think? What is the reason he kept unnoticed for ten years. Or we should say, he was noticed before by many, but nobody took action (as said in one of the posts). What is your opinion how this could be happened?

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Anonymous,

    Well, I also want to know "how he got away with his fake identity"!
    To answer that, I think we need to know what happened first.

    Yes, maybe someone noticed some problems before, but I don't really know. Even if you notice a problem, it might be not easy to stand up. Also, if you do not see the full scale of the problem, you might downplay the finding as a minor problem.

    ReplyDelete
  4. He is cool we are fool :)
    Did you like the movie "Catch Me If You Can?"

    ReplyDelete
  5. I hope he learned how to perform seppuku after all those years in Japan. I'm terribly ashamed of him as a fellow Turk. I don't know if it means anything but I want to apologize in the name of that crook.

    ReplyDelete
  6. denver broncos jerseys, http://www.denverbroncos.org/
    ralph lauren outlet, http://www.ralphlaurenoutletuk.org.uk/
    lululemon outlet, http://www.yogapants.us.com/
    ugg outlet uk, http://www.snowboots.us.com/
    chanel outlet store, http://www.chaneloutletstore.us.com/
    steelers jerseys, http://www.pittsburghsteelersjersey.com/
    louis vuitton bags cheap, http://www.louisvuittonbag.us.com/
    michael kors outlet online, http://michaelkors.outletonlinestores.us.com/
    miami dolphins jerseys, http://www.miamidolphinsjersey.com/
    san antonio spurs, http://www.sanantoniospursjersey.com/
    nike shoes, http://www.cheap-nikeshoes.cc/
    tory burch outlet, http://www.toryburchshoesoutlet.com/
    michael kors outlet online, http://www.michaelkorsoutletusa.net/
    celine outlet, http://www.celineoutletus.com/
    nike air huarache, http://www.nikeairhuarache.org.uk/
    lebron shoes, http://www.lebronjames.us.com/
    babyliss pro, http://www.babyliss.us.com/
    toms outlet store, http://www.tomsoutlet-stores.com/
    boston celtics jersey, http://www.celticsjersey.com/
    calvin klein outlet, http://www.calvinklein.in.net/
    mm1013

    ReplyDelete
  7. this is surely the best place one can get useful info about what he needs.kudos to the real admin of this site.he definately deserve the best and nothing more.

    regards,
    http://www.pusatro.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. Your blog was too good. i really appreciate with your blog.Thanks for sharing.
    ICC T20 World Cup 2016
    Australia vs India time table

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hello dear .You put really very helpful information.
    It’s pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.

    t20 world cup live stream
    ipl live streaming
    ipl 9 live streaming
    real madrid vs barcelona live streaming
    La Liga Live Streaming
    India vs Pakistan T20 Live Streaming
    India vs Pakistan T20 Live Streaming Asia Cup 2016

    ReplyDelete
  10. I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for magnificent info I was looking for this info for my mission.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Good blog post. I want to thank you for interesting and helpful information and I like your point of view. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks for the best blog.it was very useful for me.keep sharing such idea
    s in the future as well.this was actually what i was looking for,and i
    am glad to came here
    you keep up the fantastic work!my weblog
    age of war
    Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while now and finally got the
    happy wheels

    tank trouble 3

    ReplyDelete
  15. With a Hotmail account, you can send and receive emails quickly and easily as well as login and use all Microsoft services.
    hotmail review | sign in to hotmail

    This is the game so players feel very fierce , adventurous . You try to join and play this game , you will feel great like.
    strike force heroes | strike force heroes 4
    slither.io | red ball | can your pet
    happywheels | earn to die | duck life

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi i was browsing your blog and i found it really interesting! i too have a website.Kindly check it out here
    Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza
    Galaxy Blue Sapphire Noida Extension
    Galaxy Blue Sapphire
    Galaxy Blue Sapphire Plaza Noida

    ReplyDelete
  17. Amazing post, Thank you for presenting a wide variety of information that is very interesting to see in this artikle
    fireboy and watergirl game
    Geometry Dash 2.0

    ReplyDelete
  18. Want to know about Veterans Day? Why is it celebrated,how did it all start and all other details, just have a look at my blog, Happy Veterans Day 2016
    and stay updated with all the latest information

    ReplyDelete
  19. Tata Consultancy Services has launched an Enterprise Resource Planning portal dubbed as the TCS Ultimatix for better services of employees.

    ReplyDelete
  20. We are always interested in the "neglect" of us. But we are "abandoning" who cares about us ...
    Friv | Unblocked | ABCya | Yepi

    ReplyDelete
  21. Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại cầu giấy
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại từ liêm
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại thanh xuân
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại hà đông
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại long biên
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại nguyễn chính thanh đống đa
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại minh khai hai bà trưng
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại bắc ninh
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại hải phòng
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại tphcm
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại quận 3
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại thủ đức
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại đà nẵng
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại biên hòa
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại đồng nai
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại nam định
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại thái bình
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại bắc giang
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại vĩnh phúc
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại thái nguyên
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại quảng ninh
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại hải dương
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại hưng yên
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại hà nam
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại ninh bình
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại nghệ an
    Đào tạo kế toán thực hành Tại vũng tàu

    ReplyDelete
  22. To have a better exposure to your facebook account, Folks spend bucks to Buy Facebook Followers to quickly get hype on internet. buy real and permanent facebook followers

    ReplyDelete
  23. This is the game so players feel very fierce , adventurous . You try to join and play this game , you will feel great like.
    | tank trouble | learn to fly
    gun mayhem | can your pet
    | happ wheels

    ReplyDelete
  24. At age 18, we ended the year 12, officially entered the age themselves must take responsibility for themselves, face the risk of jail if do violate the law. 18 is said to be on my own, but in the culture of our country are still going to school is also covered, so it can not yet fully mature called.
    slither.io l slitherio l slither io l slither

    ReplyDelete
  25. Coach Outlet http://www.coachoutletfactory-stores.us.com

    North Face Outlet http://www.northface-outlets.com.co

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadefactoryoutlet.in.net

    ED Hardy Outlet http://www.edhardypopsale.com

    Coach Outlet Store Online http://www.coachstoreonline.in.net

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadeoutletstore.in.net

    Cheap Jordans http://www.cheapjordansretro.us.com

    Michael Kors Outlet Store http://www.michaelkorsoutletsstores.us.com

    Coach Purses http://www.coachpurses.eu.com

    Coach Outlet http://www.coachoutlet2016.us.com

    Tory Burch Shoes http://www.toryburch-outlet.us.org

    Longchamp Outlet http://www.longchampoutlet.in.net

    Michael Kors Handbags http://www.innnov8.com

    Coach Outlet http://www.innnovate.com

    Red Bottom Shoes http://www.redbottomshoes.us.org

    Moncler Jackets http://www.monclerdownjackets.us.com

    North Face Outlet http://www.northfacestoreoutlet.in.net

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadeoutletstore.us.com

    Moncler Outlet http://www.moncleroutletonline.in.net

    Coach Factory http://www.maganates.com

    Coach Factory Outlet http://www.coachfactorysoutlet.in.net

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katesapdeoutlet.us.org

    Ray Ban Outlet http://www.raybanoutletstore.in.net

    Christian Louboutin Shoes http://www.christianlouboutinshoes2016.in.net

    North Face Outlet http://www.northfaceoutlets.us.org

    Coach Factory Outlet http://www.coachoutletstore.name

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadeoutletonline.name

    Coach Outlet http://www.coach-outlets.us.org

    Nike Roshe Run http://www.tanie-nikerosherun.pl

    Buty Nike Air Max http://www.airmaxsprzedazdla.pl

    Nike Air Max http://www.nikeairmax.us.org

    Red Bottom Shoes http://www.redbottomshoe.in.net

    Christian Louboutin Outlet http://www.christianlouboutinoutlet.us.org

    Balenciaga Handbags http://www.balenciagaoutlets.us.com

    Balenciaga Handbags http://www.balenciaga-handbags.us.com

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadefactoryoutlet.in.net

    Toms Shoes http://www.tomshoesoutlet.us.com

    Hermes Belt http://www.hermes-belts.us.com

    Prada Outlet http://www.pradafactoryoutlet.com

    Louis Vuitton Outlet http://www.louisvuittonsoutlet.us.com

    North Face Outlet Store http://www.northfaceoutletstore.in.net

    North Face Jackets http://www.north-face.in.net

    North Face http://www.north-faceoutlets.us.com

    Louis Vuitton Outlet http://www.louisvuitton-outlets.us.org

    Timberland Boots http://www.timberland-outlets.us.com

    Cheap Timberland Boots http://www.timberlandoutlet.us.com

    Tory Burch Outlet http://www.outlettoryburch.us.com

    Michael Kors Outlet http://www.michaelkorsoutletusa.us.com

    Ralph Lauren Outlet http://www.ralphlaurenstoreoutlet.us.com

    Gucci Shoes http://www.guccifactoryoutlet.name

    Gucci Outlet http://www.guccioutletco.us.com

    North Face Jackets http://www.northfacefactoryoutlet.us.com

    Prada Outlet http://www.pradaoutlets.in.net

    Hollister Clothing http://www.hollister-clothing.us.com

    Ferragamo Shoes http://www.ferragamoshoes.us.org

    Tiffany Outlet http://www.tiffany-outlets.us.com

    Tiffany Outlet http://www.tiffanyco-outlet.us.com

    NFL Jerseys http://www.nfljerseys.name

    Toms Outlet http://www.outlettoms.us.com

    Cheap Jordans http://www.cheapjordans.eu.com

    North Face Outlet http://www.thenorthfaceoutlet.us.org

    Michael Kors Outlet http://www.michael-korsoutletstores.us.com

    Prada Handbags http://www.pradaoutlet.us.org

    Chan Luu Sale http://www.chanluu.us.com

    Toms Outlet http://www.tomsoutletstores.us.com

    Kate Spade Outlet http://www.katespadeoutletonline.us.org

    Beats By Dr Dre http://www.beatsbydrdre.us.org

    Coach Outlet http://www.coachstoreoutlet.us.org

    Christian Louboutin Shoes http://www.christianlouboutinshoe.eu.com

    Valentino Shoes http://www.valentinoshoes.eu.com

    Michael Kors Outlet http://www.michaelkorsoutlet.us.org

    Coach Factory Outlet http://www.coachfactoryoutlet.us.org

    Coach Outlet Online http://www.coachoutletonlinestore.us.org

    Coach Purses http://www.coachpurse.us.com

    ReplyDelete

  26. Everyone loves the look and feel of a clean home. Thanks for choosing this topic for post and update me. Game Stick RPG 2 looks like your real life, you can get everything you want, game Douchebag workout 2 is to renew him, so that he can hook up with the sexy girl appearing in the introduction, return man saves your progress, with Potty Racers do you want to fly to Mars with me?

    ReplyDelete